GreenfieldNOW.com
search all things local
     
Blog Home |  Email Author  |        Welcome to MyCommunityNOW - Blogs Sign in | Join

Wag the Dog

Why does a dog wag its tail? Because a dog is smarter than its tail. If the tail was smarter, the tail would wag the dog! An old joke that applys to today.

Hard Decisions Ahead for FPS

By Bryan Maersch
Friday, Jun 6 2008, 07:00 AM
I have had time to digest the information that was presented to public in the first draft presentation of the 2009 Franklin Public School budget. Especially the excellent Blog Report and suggestions made by FranklinNOW blogger Janet Evans. I admire her tenacity and dedication as to reporting and participating in the Franklin Public School meetings.

From the reports that came from other bloggers who attended the meeting one thing stood out that disturbs me, was the opinion of Superintendent Patz on funding extracurricular activities by increasing fee’s.  I hope this is not a reaction that all School Board members feel the same.

 FranklinNOW blogger Greg Kowalski reported:

Superintendent Patz and at least one Board member (I forgot whom exactly) didn't like the idea of fee increases, stating that the increases would lead to discrimination of students based on how much they (or their families) can afford, and that it will end up negligible in the end. I'll profoundly disagree.As a member of a 5-member household, with 2 very active younger sisters, I know firsthand of some extra-circular activities. Volleyball, basketball, summer camp, dancing, gymnastics, etc, etc, etc. All those cost money, and I can assure anyone that my family isn't the wealthiest in Franklin. We afford it, and it's what my sisters want to do. I stood in agreement with Board President Dave Szychlinski when he talked about his own family and daughters, and how he'd be more than happy to pay the extra fees if some of things they took were offered at FPS.  I believe many families would join my own and the Szychlinski's.

I do not understand the not-thinking-outside-the-box attitude Patz is taking on this issue. A simple change to funding extracurriculars would allow for a parent that can not afford to pay the fees for the extracurriculars could simply fill out a form (such as the one for subsidized lunch) to allow the school system to subsidize that student for the extracurricular activity. Considering the average family income in the City of Franklin, I would tend to doubt that this would be a large financial burden on the FPS budget but the increased fees would help defray costs to actually pay to educate our children.

I totally agree with Greg’s statement:

FPS needs to prioritize their budget for the taxpayers in this rough time for our economy. Do they support academics, or athletics? I'd like to use common sense and take academics as the top priority, so we should focus on other alternatives to fund athletics. 

Superintendent Patz, please don’t start telling us what we can’t do, start thinking of more ways that we can keep the budget down, even if it means unpopular fees to people who use a FPS service that is non-academic.  That's not WAGGING THE DOG, that is just Common Sense.

On a positive note, the Board is doing a great job at keeping the taxpayer informed and involving them in the budget process.

Kudos to them to realize this is crucial especially in rough economic times.

Comments

Janet Evans   

Bryan,

Thanks for your thoughts about my reporting on the School Board.

I understand where you and Greg and coming from regarding the extra-curricular activities.  And, I know there are many who will agree with you.  I was getting ready to respond on Greg’s blog when I saw your blog, so I am going to address both of you.  Greg already knows I have differing views on this.  And it’s not that I’m not thinking “out-of-the-box, either.  I’m trying to put the responsibility where it should go first.  

You see, we’re talking about making “budget cuts.”  And I guess I don’t see raising extra-curricular fees…the fees for those students who participate in activities above and beyond the regular school day…where they must attain a set passing GPA…where they bring acknowledgement, pride, and recognition to their school and city is the first place we should look.  I’m not saying we should never raise those fees.  And I want to clarify that Dr. Patz was trying to convey that raising the extra –curricular fees too much might discourage some families from participating in general, I think just because they are tired of everything going up in price right now.  It isn’t that they are the families that would qualify for filling out the form you are speaking about.

Take a look at the budget link on my blog.  It sure doesn’t look to me like the Board batted an eye at Administrative raises.  Sounds like Dave Szychlinski, who doesn’t have children in the schools (his children and my daughter, in her thirties, graduated together) acknowledged he didn’t know the current fees or how they compare to other districts.  Why can’t the Board try to make cuts from within first before going out and asking for more money from the citizens.  We already pay taxes.  To me that’s just the easy way out.  They need to tighten their belts first.  

That list I compiled ….the district can go through every inch of their operation with a fine tooth comb.  They can run the entire District more like a business instead of only the Business Dept. being run that way, and they will be guaranteed to save some money.  Then they should come out to the families and ask for more money.  And when that time comes, then by all means raise the fees.  But perhaps, since all students in Phy Ed. use the sports facilities, start by raising regular student fees for all students first.  Then charge or raise fees for entering sporting and fine arts events, along with raising extra curricular fees.

I still say, when we have so many Administrators making such large salaries in our district last year:

James Milzer Business Manager $119,893

Judy Mueller Central Office Administrator $108,574

Michael Cady Principal 101,630

Karen Zalucha Director of InstructionSupervisor $100,114

Paulette Kroll Director of Special Education $97,920

Matthew Lesar Principal $95,942

Charles Wedig Principal $91,538

Lawrence Madsen Principal $89,461

Phillip Posard Principal $87,859

Michael Zellmer Central Office Administrator $84,201

Thomas Reinke Principal $81,134

Sally Carlson School Social Worker $78,152

Carol Dixon Principal $77,982

Gregory Jenks School Psychologist $76,240

Jeff Nelson Assistant Principal $74,995

John Budish Assistant Principal $72,000

Mark Finne School Social Worker $70,907

Jamie Foeckler Assistant Principal $69,500

Luann Zielinski District Inst Tech. Coordinator $69,500

Maybe one year without a 3 percent raise wouldn’t kill them.

June 6, 2008 12:07 PM

FranklinParent   

Thank you for this commentary. I wholeheartedly agree. Funny thing is that the type of fees you are talking about will likely hit my household the hardest. We'll be in the middle. Not eligible for subsidies, but tightening the financial belt enough that we might have to forego an expensive extracurricular.

Discrimination - no, life lesson yes. We aren't always entitled to the extras in life. If we were, my mini van would be the one with the custom flamejob.

June 6, 2008 1:31 PM

Leave a Comment

Please Sign In to post comment.

About Bryan Maersch

A former reporter for several local radio stations, Bryan is now a computer geek for a large Life Insurance Company. Bryan decided to join FranklinNOW as a blogger to provide a viewpoint from a realistic Franklin Taxpayer, Dad and Husband. DISCLAIMER: The opinions stated on this blog are those of the writer only and do not reflect or are not connected in any way to his employer.